Evidence of SuccessEvidence of Failures and WeaknessesEvidence the Plans Were Not Well Planned
Massive growth in heavy industry: steel, coal, and electricity production soared.Consumer goods industries (e.g. textiles, housing) were neglected.Targets constantly revised upwards to unrealistic levels (target mania).
Impressive large-scale projects (e.g. Dnieprostroi Dam, Moscow Metro).Oil production repeatedly failed to meet targets, leading to fuel crises.Poor coordination between sectors and at local levels.
USSR became nearly self-sufficient in machine-making by late 1930s.High wastage and production of sub-standard goods.Frequent shortages of materials due to unrealistic quotas.
Magnitogorsk and other new cities symbolised industrial progress.Skilled labour shortage caused job instability and low productivity.Bribery, hoarding, and corruption rampant to meet targets.
Electricity and engineering output greatly increased.Workers frequently changed jobs; high labour turnover.Factories overproduced unwanted goods while others lacked essentials.
Significant transport and communications development.Absenteeism and poor discipline common among ex-peasant workers.Few officials admitted failures for fear of persecution.
Foreign specialists helped with initial setup of key industries.Quality control was poor; defective goods were still used.‘Bourgeois specialists’ purged, leading to loss of experienced staff.
USSR developed strong defence and arms industries by WWII.Housing and living conditions for workers were often appalling.First plan lacked detailed, practical planning—more propaganda-driven.